The following article contains affiliate links, which means Sex Toy Magazine may earn commission from services purchased through links in this post. If you love our work, know that the commissions help with keeping Sex Toy Magazine a 100% ad-free experience.
If you are reading this, you probably already know what a Fleshlight is.
This little toy is arguably the most well known of all male masturbation toys and has revolutionized solo sex for many penis-owners worldwide.
Fleshlight Girls series in particular is great. These Fleshlights are molded to look and feel exactly as the holes of some of the best and most well-known adult stars on the planet.
Now, as a sex toy blogger and collector, I am still in awe just how little rep anal Fleshlight Girls get in the community. Sure, there are some hits here and there…but for some reason, anal Fleshlights are simply not as popular as Fleshlights molded to look and feel like vaginas.
And it’s a damn shame!
You see, there are many fantastic anal Fleshlights out there. Some of them feel realistic. Some of them feel intensely tight. And some of them stimulate the penis in ways that are pretty hard to describe (I’ll do my best though).
As you may have already guessed, I’ll dive deep into my own collection and give you my thoughts on the best anal Fleshlights currently out there. All in the hopes of helping you fine people choose an anal orifice fitted to what type of experience you are after.
Some of my choices are tested and tried Fleshlight community favorites. Meanwhile, some others have gotten way too little attention in the Reddit Fleshlight community and other resources that discuss anal Fleshlights.
How did I choose? Well, to me, the anal experience is about the mystery, the anticipation, the forbidden, and sometimes sheer tightness. It is not something to be treated as an average sexual experience. At least in my book.
And, the sleeves I chose are, according to my penis, the best replications of that sometimes nearly mythical anal experience.
Without further ado, let’s get our minds horny and our members hard.
These are the best anal Fleshlights as chosen by Sex Toy Magazine:
• Best for Penis Milking: Mia Malkova – Boss Level
• Best for Slow, Deep Penetration: LaSirena69 – Tesoro
• The Sexiest Anal Fleshlight: Autumn Falls – Peaches
• Most Intricate Texture Design: Kazumi – Bumzumi
• Best For Steady & Rhythmic Thrusting: Blake Blossom – Boom
• Most Stimulating Texture: Violet Myers – Ahegao
• Most Realistic Anal Experience: Stoya – Epic
• Best For Fast Masturbation: Vanna Bardot – Oxytocin
Best for Penis Milking: Mia Malkova – Boss Level
Find best offers at Fleshlight
- Who it’s for: People who want to go for the sure thing and experience a cult favorite Fleshlight that strikes a perfect balance of tightness, softness, and texture variations.
Let’s start with the classics! There will be some underlooked Fleshlights on this list, but Boss Level is certainly not one of them.
It is one of the most well-known and highly-rated anal Fleshlights out there. And for good reason.
The sleeve design here is just right. You get a sort of Vortex-like entrance that feels as if it’s drawing your penis in. In a way, it feels almost like you are using a penis milking machine!
This is only the start though. Once you are in the sleeve, things become a bit calmer. There are no real texture variations inside. All you have is the slightly rotating tunnel that’s filled to the brim with soft nubs.
This combination of a more relaxed interior with a super intense entrance is to die for.
For me, the Boss Level experience is all about the in-and-out. I literally get my penis fully out of the Fleshlight in-between stroking instead of just staying in. It adds an amazing sort of variation to the experience and just sort of works.
I once even managed to accidentally shoot my load on the entrance when pulling out. I’m telling you – there’s something about how that entrance makes way to the inner texture that just does wild things to people. A true zone of danger!
Oh, and that entrance/relaxed interior combo has also made it a very popular sleeve among enthusiasts of edging and folks who want to improve their sexual stamina.
Best for Slow, Deep Penetration: LaSirena69 – Tesoro
Find best offers at Fleshlight
- Who it’s for: Deep and slow stroke enthusiasts who prefer a lighter, almost handjob-like take on the anal experience.
Super, super underrated.
LaSirena69 is amazing and when I heard that she is collabing with Fleshlight, I was excited to say the least.
And her anal Fleshlight did not disappoint and remains in rotation for me.
If I was to describe this one with a word, it would be “different”
First things first – Tesoro is not a realistic anal Fleshlight. It offers a completely different take on an anal sleeve.
The entrance here is properly tight. Not insanely tight, but the familiar anal Fleshlight grip is there.
The magic here lies in what’s inside though.
Penetrating Tesoro feels almost as if you are getting a silky handjob or something. The texture feels as if there are pockets of air inside – your penis goes through variations of tight and light. With plenty of lube, it will feel like some sort of exquisite, high-end penis massage that feels velvety and almost royal.
Sure, you will want to shoot your load, but you will also want to enjoy this sensation for as long as possible.
For this one, make sure to go slow and as deep as the Fleshlight allows. This kind of almost romantic penetration will show you that it’s not always about sheer tightness and intensity when it comes to anal Fleshlights.
Some sleeves like the Testoro reveal themselves discreetly and slowly.
The Sexiest Anal Fleshlight: Autumn Falls – Peaches
- Who it’s for: People who want to go through different texture and stimulation variations in a single Fleshlight sleeve. Also for lovers of aesthetics – this hole does look gorgeous.
With this one, I want to start by saying that both the anal and vagina Fleshlights of Autumn Falls are top 5 all-time sleeves when it comes to how they look. That subtle, Latina tan is to die for and makes you want to wiggle your member inside it immediately after getting the Fleshlight out of the box.
Looks only go skin deep though. What makes Peaches pop is how it feels. Somewhat similar to Boss Level, Peaches starts off very intensely.
The entry is tight, gripping, and newcomers will find it tempting to shoot their load immediately.
Try to resist though because most good Fleshlights hit the best when you go full-in. This is the case for Peaches too.
Once you get past the tight opening, you are greeted with soft nub-like details in the middle section. They are relatively soft in how they feel, but they are pretty big when compared to most other anal Fleshlights on this list.
This creates a unique type of stimulation where you kind of feel as if there are fingers squeezing your penis. In a good way.
The sleeve ends with a smoother, more relaxed area. And the placement of this one is amazing. The smooth end truly does feel like a finishing line. A place for you to rest your penis and just shoot your load into the very end of this fantastic sleeve.
In fact, I once did manage to fall asleep with this thing fully wrapped around my penis. Not a good idea in terms of the mess I made, but yeah…the relaxing effects of a good anal Fleshlight I guess.
Most Intricate Texture Design: Kazumi – Bumzumi
- Who it’s for: Those who want a tight, gripping experience that can feel almost mythical at times due to the intricate texture design.
This one is a certified legend. The adult star Kazumi who inspired the aptly named Bumzumi is known for some rather raunchy stuff and her anal Fleshlight follows suit.
Let’s just get to the point – Bumzumi is tight, gripping, and intense. The textures inside look and feel like a damn maze at times. You stick your member in and pretty much immediately feel as if the entirety of the sleeve wants to suck the orgasm out of you.
Even if you are a veteran of things like blowjob machines, sex doll torsos, or penis vibrators…the Bumzumi will still feel like something new to you.
Yes, it feels that insane!
What’s even more surprising is that the Bumzumi doesn’t care whether you go slow or fast – regardless of your penetration approach, this sleeve will want to get your balls empty as soon as possible.
Is this my favorite anal Fleshlight of all-time? I’m not quite sure. What I do know for sure is that the Bumzumi is the best sleeve for showcasing people just how damn intense, stimulating, and almost weird a male sex toy can feel like.
I have no idea how it feels to be inside the butt of Kazumi, but if this anal Fleshlight is even remotely close to the real thing then…well, not hard to see why Kazumi is one of the most popular adult stars around right now.
Best For Steady & Rhythmic Thrusting: Blake Blossom – Boom
- Who it’s for: Guys who love rhythmic thrusting and want a tight-but-not-aggressive anal experience.
Blake Blossom is not known for her anal ventures. Despite being one of the most in-demand adult stars working right now, anal is something that we don’t associate her with.
As such, I was pretty intrigued what the collaboration between Blake and Fleshlight looks like.
To my surprise, Bloom is a great sleeve.
In a word, I would describe it as “rhythmic”.
No intense gripping, no crazy texture variations, and really…no surprises. Is this a bad thing? Hell no.
You see, this one follows the rhythm of your stroking to a T. It is super hard to describe the sensation, but you almost feel as if you are really having sex with Blake or some other imaginary woman. And a very enthusiastic woman at that.
Due to everything I described, the Boom can at times feel like something other than a Fleshlight. Almost a vibrating toy type of a feel there.
Also, it keeps me hard. Literally. I stay hard for a good five minutes even after finishing. Provided that I remain inside the sleeve.
I’m telling you – there is some kind of magic in how that one is designed.
Would I get it as my first ever anal Fleshlight? No. Would I get it as a collector or someone looking for a completely different anal Fleshlight experience? Hell yeah!
Most Stimulating Texture: Violet Myers – Ahegao
- Who it’s for: People who like sheer tightness and want to experience one of the most acclaimed anal Fleshlights on the market.
Ahegao is another anal Fleshlight that has firmly established itself as a cult favorite. When looking for recommendations on which one to get, then you’ll pretty quickly find this one recommended in Reddit communities and other online Fleshlight resources.
And it’s worth the hype too.
It is pretty similar to Bumzumi in the sense that it’s damn crazy. There is nothing smooth in Ahegao. It is airtight and also has loads of different texture variations inside it. A double treat of intensity!
The name seems to imply that Ahegao is inspired by anime…and honestly, it makes sense.
The feeling of penetrating this does bring to mind some of the weirdest Hentai scenes I have ever seen. And this is obviously a good thing.
Not sure how they managed this, but pretty much all sessions with Ahegao feel different from the last one. Sometimes, it feels as if it’s the tip that gets the best treatment. Sometimes it feels slightly lighter while sometimes it feels as if it’s one of the tightest sleeves I have ever been in.
All in all, a deserved hall-of-famer, this. Aggressive, bumpy, incredibly stimulating, and mysterious.
Most Realistic Anal Experience: Stoya – Epic
Find best offers at Fleshlight
- Who it’s for: Those that are looking for a realistic, eerily tight anal experience where you feel almost as if you’ll “hurt” your Fleshlight.
Epic is firmly the oldest release on this list of best anal Fleshlights. And, it also happens to be one of the most famous ones here.
First, let’s take a minute to give kudos to how it looks. It is one beautiful, detailed little butthole that just screams for you to get in.
Speaking of getting in – the Epic is a very good rendition of a realistic anal experience. It is damn gripping right from the get to. Pop in and you almost feel your head getting sucked in to the vortex.
And it doesn’t get any better once you are inside. It is tight and snug from the start to the very end. And realistic!
If you’ve ever enjoyed anal then you know that watching your tempo and intensity carefully is key to making sure that both you and your partner are alright.
Well, the Stoya Fleshlight feels realistic to the point where you kind of automatically penetrate it super carefully in order to “not hurt” your dear Fleshlight. I am pretty damn average in the size department and even I felt as if I was going to “break” Stoya with my penis. It’s that damn tight!
There’s nothing more to say really – in terms of sheer intensity and levels of suctioning stimulation, Epic still remains one of the best examples there is.
And it’s a revolutionary one too. Epic is one of the sleeves that made Fleshlight Girls series so damn popular. Glad to see it is still getting hype!
A well-deserved hall-of-famer.
Best For Fast Masturbation: Vanna Bardot – Oxytocin
- Who it’s for: Lovers of a steady, unchanging pattern. A great fit for seekers of a fast release.
If you’re the type who likes their pleasure predictable, then Oxytocin will hit the spot. This isn’t a sleeve with lots of chambers, twists, and surprises. Instead, you have a fairly consistent texture with alternating pockets and ribs.
The same ride from where you enter to where you finish.
This repetition feels like a continuous tug on your penis. Almost as if someone wearing the softest Velvet glove is tugging your stuff relatively intensely.
This tug-type of feeling is particularly what makes the Oxytocin pop. Some other anal Fleshlights on this list are also comparable to a handjob, but with this one, the handjob feels super deliberate and fast. Even if your stroking is slow, the feel of penetrating this feels rushed somehow.
Like someone wants to get you off with their hand as fast as humanly possible.
In general, I am all for things like teasing, edging, and milking as much time and fun out of my Fleshlights as possible. The Oxytocin though – this one works best for a quick ride. If you just want to get your rocks off as fast as possible (nothing wrong with that) then this one will do the trick.
So, this is the cream of the crop of anal Fleshlights. Honestly, whichever of these beautiful little sleeves you end up choosing, you’ll still have a lot of fun. All of them are acclaimed in Fleshlight communities.
And, even more importantly, all of them have been tested on my dear old penis as well. And he loves them!
For me, it’s time to head to bed right now. Who knows, I’ll also might take one of these beautiful anal Fleshlights with me.
All the best, gentlemen!
